Was Cristobal Navarra taking a shortcut or planning a burglary?
Navarra ended up struggling with Juan Carlos Kennedy. Then Kennedy’s son, Carlos Kennedy, joined in the struggle. At least one of them started beating him to death with a golf club.
Police say the father and son were justified in killing Navarra, however, Navarra’s family believes he was wrongly killed. They insist that he was not going to break into the house, but was only cutting through their yard as a shortcut to get away from the rain.
Police say they will not file charges against the father and son. But the incident does bring into question the state's law that protects property owners from being punised for defending what's theirs. In 2005, Gov. Jeb Bush signed what is referred to as the "Stand Your Ground" law, which states that citizens who use deadly force in self-defense are immune from criminal prosecution and civil liability.
Before the passing of the law, deadly force only applied to intruders who entered the home, and even then people had the burden of proof to show they feared for their safety.
The current law now includes the area outside of one's home, but the homeowner must "reasonably believe" that deadly force is necessary.
Some believe the law simply encourages vigilantism.