Miami Beach

2 Men Now Facing Murder Charges in Miami Beach Spring Break Overdoses

Evoire Collier, 21, and Dorian Taylor, 25, charged after deaths of Christine Englehardt and Walter Riley

NBC Universal, Inc.

Two North Carolina men accused of raping a 24-year-old tourist who overdosed during spring break in Miami Beach now face first-degree murder charges.

On Wednesday, a grand jury in Miami-Dade County found Evoire Collier, 21, and Dorian Taylor, 25, both from Greensboro, North Carolina, responsible for the fentanyl-induced death in March of Christine Englehardt of Richboro, Pennsylvania. She met the men while visiting South Beach, and went with them to her room at the Albion Hotel, prosecutors said.

The grand jury added a second first-degree murder charge against Taylor for supplying the same opioid to Walter Riley, 21, from Chicago. He was found unconscious on a nearby street and died March 20, two days after Englehardt was found unresponsive in her hotel room, the Miami Herald reported.

Miami-Dade Corrections
Evoire Collier and Dorian Taylor

The three-page grand jury report accuses the pair of killing Englehardt with their “unlawful distribution of fentanyl” while committing sexual battery and burglary. The men allegedly took Englehardt's credit cards and made illegal purchases at SOBE Liquors and the Sugar Factory.

Collier’s attorney, Phil Reizenstein, told the Herald he's “stunned” by the indictment. He said the medical examiner found Englehardt had ingested so many different drugs that it was nearly impossible to pin down what caused her death.

“I think they’re going to regret doing this,” said Reizenstein. “I think by the time I’m finished with them, they’re never going to be able to say she died of this.”

Taylor’s attorney, Liesbeth Boot, couldn’t be reached.

The men were arrested March 21, according to jail records. Both appeared in court Thursday where they were formally charged with first-degree murder, and had their trial date set for Nov. 18. Prosecutors said they would seek the death penalty for both.

Christine Englehardt
Christine Englehardt is seen in a Facebook photo.

Authorities said surveillance video captured the men entering the hotel with Englehardt and later leaving without her. An arrest report says Collier confessed to giving Englehardt a green pill and claimed they sexually assaulted her in the hotel room even as she lay unconscious.

The Miami-Dade Medical Examiner determined the pills ingested by Englehardt were “rapidly fatal” fentanyl. The autopsy also found that her alcohol level when she died hovered near 0.2%, almost three times the legal limit, and asphyxia may have played a role in her death, the Herald reported.

AP and NBC 6
Contact Us