Judge Stays Put in FIU Stabbing Case

Judge with ties to lead murder detective refuses to remove herself from trial

The judge overseeing the murder trial of slain Florida International football star Kendall Berry refused to remove herself from the case during a Thursday hearing.

Circuit Judge Beatrice Butchko said she'll continue on the case despite her close ties to the lead detective, according to the Miami Herald.

Butchko officiated the wedding ceremony of Miami-Dade homicide Det. Ray Hoadley four years ago, but said she didn't stay for the reception.

The attorney for Quentin Wyche, who was arrested and charged in the March 26 stabbing of Berry on FIU's campus, had asked Butchko to recuse herself from the case to ensure a "fair and impartial" trial.

Butchko denied the request Thursday, saying it was not "legally sufficient."

Wyche's lawyer said he may still appeal her ruling.

Wyche, 22, has been charged with second-degree murder in the death of Berry.

According to police, the incident began at the school's rec center when Wyche insulted Berry's girlfriend and threw cookies in her face. As the two men exchanged words and the argument became physical, Wyche stabbed Berry with an unknown object.

Wyche was later arrested after turning himself in to police.

The 22-year-old Berry, a running back for FIU, was remembered as a great player with an "infectious personality" by Golden Panthers coach Mario Cristbal.

Contact Us