How Retailers Grade You to Determine Customer Treatment - NBC 6 South Florida
NBC 6 Responds

NBC 6 Responds

Responding to every consumer complaint

How Retailers Grade You to Determine Customer Treatment



    How Retailers Grade You to Determine Customer Treatment

    It’s a secret score that shadows your almost-every move as a consumer and determines the prices you pay and the perks you receive. Yet experts told NBC 6 Responds the majority of consumers will probably never see it.

    (Published Friday, Feb. 15, 2019)

    From retailers to wireless carriers to airlines, some businesses are busy crunching data to give shoppers a secret score called a CLV or “Customer Lifetime Value”.

    It’s a projection used not only to estimate what a customer may be worth over time, but in some cases, how well to treat them.

    It’s a grade experts said is based on things like how much you spend, age, zip code, marital status, even details on your social media profiles.

    So why are businesses doing this?

    Pet Sitter Application Issues

    [MI] Pet Sitter Application Issues

    NBC 6's Sasha Jones reports.

    (Published Monday, March 4, 2019)

    Experts said it’s to hold on to their best customers.

    “When you call in, when you either have a complaint or when you’re seeking some sort of discount, or when you’re saying, ‘Hey, my neighbor got this but I didn’t get this,’ they’re going to know who you are and, if they’re really sophisticated about it, they’ll know whether you really deserve it or not,” said Pete Fader, a marketing professor.

    Shoppers with a high score probably make frequent purchases and spend more money and would be more likely to get a call or email answered fast or get a refund without much trouble.

    Student Struggles With Visual Impairment

    [MI] Student Struggles With Visual Impairment

    A local college student says he’s working toward becoming a teacher, despite having a visual impairment. But when the FIU student said he hit new hurdles, he decided to ask NBC 6 Responds for help. Alina Machado explains.

    (Published Friday, March 1, 2019)

    “It’s going to be purely based on what you’ve done and what we think you’re going to do next,” Fader said.

    In short, Fader said a customer’s CLV comes down to the relationship with the retailer.

    “If we see you engaging with the company more deeply, we have a sense that you’re going to be worth just that much more in the future,” Fader explained.

    Closed Business Leaves Customers Waiting Weeks for Refund

    [MI] Closed Business Leaves Customers Waiting Weeks for Refund

    Homeowners reached out to NBC 6 Responds after waiting weeks for refund checks to arrive in the mail from home warranty company Service America. The company closed its doors in January, but some customers told us refund checks they were promised never arrived.

    (Published Wednesday, Feb. 27, 2019)

    Retailers don’t share this information with each other. Your CLV is different each place you spend money.

    Some consumer advocates think customers should be clued-in to their secret score.

    John Breyault from the National Consumers League said more pressure is needed on regulators for companies to release the grades.

    “If these scores are being used to make important decisions about me, decisions about what kind of offers I’m going to be accepted as a customer at a bank or a company, then I think consumers deserve to know that and I think it’s an area where consumers are demanding more control,” Breyault said.

    The scores essentially might frame you as a serial returner, chronic complainer or just a plain old cheapskate. If that’s not accurate, privacy experts said that is why consumers should have a chance to review their secret score.

    We asked the National Retail Federation for a comment on this practice. They told us they don’t follow the issue.

    Get the latest from NBC 6 anywhere, anytime